Short answer: Caramel Noir from D&E Fragrances is our Extrait de Parfum take on Penhaligon's Changing Constance, from £14.99 to £44.95, while the original costs around £245 for 75ml. Shop Caramel Noir here.
- Smells like: spiced salted butter caramel over smoky tobacco and vanilla.
- Best for: cooler days and evenings when you want something warm and gourmand.
- Honest note: it is our own interpretation, not an exact copy.
Changing Constance is one of the most talked-about gourmand fragrances from Penhaligon's, and it is easy to see why. It is warm, sweet and a little bit smoky, but it also carries a luxury price tag. If you love the idea of a caramel scent with real depth, you may be wondering whether there is a more affordable way to enjoy that style.
What does Changing Constance actually smell like?
According to UK retailers, Changing Constance opens with cardamom and pimento, which add a gentle spice and a hint of warmth. The heart is salted butter caramel, the note that gives the fragrance its identity: sweet, rich and slightly savoury at the same time. The base is made up of cashmeran, tobacco and vanilla, which bring a soft, smoky, cosy finish.
Why people look for a Changing Constance dupe
The main reason is price. At around £245 for a 75ml bottle, it is a real investment, and the bottle is also reported as being out of stock at some retailers from time to time. Gourmand fans often want to wear their favourite scent daily, and that is much easier to do when a bottle costs a fraction of the price. Others simply want to try the style first before committing to the original.
| Penhaligon's Changing Constance | Caramel Noir (D&E) | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Around £245 for 75ml | From £14.99 to £44.95 |
| Style | Salted caramel, tobacco, vanilla | Warm gourmand amber in the same style |
| Format | Eau de Parfum | Extrait de Parfum |
| Sizes | 75ml | 5ml, 12ml roller, 15ml, 30ml, 50ml |
Introducing Caramel Noir
Caramel Noir is our own composition, inspired by the style of Changing Constance. It opens with a touch of spice, moves into a sweet and salty caramel heart, and dries down to a smoky tobacco and vanilla base. Because it comes in five sizes, you can start with a 5ml sample for £14.99 or go straight for the 50ml bottle. Try Caramel Noir from £14.99.
Being upfront about the comparison
Caramel Noir is not an exact clone, and we would never claim it is. It captures the same broad idea, a salty caramel gourmand with a smoky base, but it is blended by us, so there will be differences in detail and character. If you love the original, we suggest ordering a sample and judging it on your own skin.
Longevity and projection
Our fragrances are Extrait de Parfum, which means a higher concentration of fragrance oils. Most people can expect around 8-10+ hours of wear, though this varies with skin type, weather and how many sprays you wear. Gourmand scents often feel stronger in cooler weather, so Caramel Noir is a good autumn and winter pick.
The verdict
If you want the cosy, salty caramel and tobacco feel of Changing Constance without paying luxury prices, Caramel Noir is worth trying. Shop Caramel Noir now and see how it wears for you.
Follow us for daily dupes: TikTok @defragrances26 and Instagram @defragrance.25.
Caramel Noir is our own original composition, inspired by the fragrance family that Changing Constance belongs to. It is not an exact replica. Penhaligon's and Changing Constance are registered trademarks of their owners; D&E Fragrances is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.
Browse more in our best fragrance dupes UK guide.